Sealed fate

Press Watch, Honolulu Star Bulletin, October 22, 2009

Molokai residents say a federal agency should not have removed a Hawaiian monk seal without their consent

Molokai residents flew to Oahu to protest a federal agency’s removal of a nearly blind Hawaiian monk seal from waters off Kaunakakai.

The residents, who held signs yesterday in front of the Waikiki Aquarium where the seal was taken, said the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration removed the seal known as “KP2” without consulting the Molokai community.

They also said the seal should have been treated for cataracts months ago.

“The kids loved that seal,” said Molokai resident Karen Holt. “There was no opportunity to say goodbye. Nothing.”

Keiko Bonk, the Hawaii program director for the Marine Conservation Biology Institute’s monk seal campaign, said there needs to be more communication between the community and NOAA seal recovery officials.

Hanohano Naehu, who lives on Molokai, said federal officials need to find a better way of working with Hawaii residents in the recovery of the monk seals, especially with the animal’s numbers increasing on the island. […]

Full Story

Seal diagnosed with cataracts

Press Watch, Honolulu Advertiser, October 20, 2009

Ailment prevents endangered animal from being set free

The first Hawaiian monk seal successfully raised from birth in captivity was diagnosed with cataracts after being plucked from Kaunakakai Harbor on Friday, which means he won’t be going back to the wild.

It’s rare to see cataracts in a seal so young.

At under 2 years old, the seal — called KP2 — is still considered an adolescent. […]

“Every individual is important to the population,” said David Schofield, NOAA marine mammal response coordinator.

Schofield said it’s believed KP2 developed cataracts at a young age because he missed out on mother’s milk.

So far, Schofield said, scientists have been unable to create a formula that matches the richness of natural seal milk.

KP2 will spend the rest of his life in captivity. Hawaiian monk seals live to be about 25 to 30 years old.

“He will likely spend the rest of his days,” Schofield said, “as an ambassador for monk seals.” […]

Full Story

KP2 Seal Taken from Molokai Yesterday

Press Watch, Molokai Dispatch, 17 October 2009

KP2, the young Hawaiian monk seal that had made Kaunakakai Wharf his home, was taken from the area by NOAA yesterday morning. He is currently being held at Waikiki Aquarium for a thorough medical exam, according to NOAA biologist David Schofield. Schofield would not say how long KP2 would remain at the aquarium or what the next move might be.

The community has mixed feelings about the seal’s departure. NOAA has discussed relocating KP2 to Ka`ula Rock near Niihau west of Kauai. Karen Holt of the Molokai Community Service Council said she is worried about the seal’s safety.

“The tiger shark population in the Ka’ula area is large and aggressive,” she explained.

Holt said she hopes that NOAA would do enough research to be able to assure those who had come to love KP2 that he would be safe.

But NOAA officials say they have believe KP2 has already survived shark  in his travels around Molokai and Lanai. They say he displays enough “wild” behaviors, like foraging on his own, that show he may still have a chance to live a normal seal’s life if relocated away from people while he is still young. NOAA officials say Niihau has the largest breeding population of Hawaiian monk seals in the Main Hawaiian Islands. […]

NOAA has not given definite plans for KP2, but as of two weeks ago, relocating him to the Niihau area as well as placing him into captivity at Sea Life Park were still in discussion.

Full Story

Kaunakakai Wharf, Molokai, Hawaii

Seal killer pleads guilty, gets 90-day term

Press Watch, Honolulu Advertiser, September 26, 2009

LIHU’E, Kaua’i — A 78-year-old Kaua’i man who shot and killed a pregnant Hawaiian monk seal in May pleaded guilty yesterday to violating the U.S. Endangered Species Act and began serving a 90-day term in the federal detention center on O’ahu.

Charles Vidinha “knew it was a Hawaiian monk seal at the time he fired his (Browning .22-caliber) rifle at her” on May 21 at Pila’a Beach, according to the plea agreement entered before Judge Barry M. Kurren yesterday. […]
Assistant U.S. Attorney Marshall Silverberg, who prosecuted the case, said because Vidinha had never had trouble with the law before and is “broke … living out of a car essentially homeless, a fine didn’t seem to be consistent with justice.”

Silvert said his research found other cases of people being sentenced to probation after unintentionally killing endangered species. […]

Full Story

Man Pleads Guilty to Killing Pregnant Monk Seal

Press Watch, KHON2, September 25, 2009

A 78-year old Kauai man accused of killing a pregnant endangered Hawaiian monk seal in May pled guilty in federal court Friday.

Court documents reveal Charles Vidinha used his browning 22-caliber rifle to fire four rounds at the seal at Pilia’a Beach on Kauai’s North Shore.

Under the terms of the plea agreement, Vidinha will serve 90 days in jail, and he won’t have to pay a fine or restitution.

If the case had gone to trial, he would’ve faced up to one year in prison and a $50,000 dollar fine.

Full Story

Hawaiian Island to Evict Over-Friendly Seal

Press Watch, Newser, September 15, 2009

Scientists fear monk seal pup raised by people will harm his human playmates

A seal pup that loves human company is facing deportation to hundreds of miles away from his Hawaiian home, the Wall Street Journal reports. Baby monk seal KP2, who often swims with people and even climbs on boogie boards, has become a much-loved local celebrity on Molokai since he showed up in February but wildlife experts warn that as he grows bigger, he may end up accidentally killing somebody by playing too rough and holding them underwater.

The problem, experts say, is that KP2, who was hand-reared by humans after being rejected by his mother, doesn’t seem to realize that he’s a seal. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration plans to move him around 200 miles away, although he soon found his way back to Molokai after an earlier effort  to remove him, and many want him to stay. “If they take him away one more time and he comes back, I don’t think this community will let NOAA take him again,” says the head of a local center that teaches children about Hawaii’s ecology.

Further info

Hawaiian Island to Evict Over-Friendly Seal, Newser,  September 15 2009

This Baby Seal Is a People Person, And That Makes Him Dangerous, Wall Street Journal, September 15, 2009