THE MEDITERRANEAN MONK SEAL IN CYPRUS

Panayiotis Dendrinos1 & Andreas Demetropoulos2,3

1 MOm/Hellenic Society for the Study and Protection of the Monk Seal
18 Solomou Str., Athens GR-10682, Greece
2 Cyprus Wildlife Society, P.O. Box 4281, Nicosia, Cyprus
3 Fisheries Department, Ministry of Agriculture, Natural Resources and Environment, Nicosia, Cyprus



Introduction

The Mediterranean monk seal (Monachus monachus) is considered to be a critically endangered species (IUCN, 1996). Its former distribution extended from the Black Sea, through the Mediterranean to the Atlantic coast of North Africa, as far south as the Cap Blanc peninsula in Mauritania. Currently, its distribution is extremely patchy with fragmentary populations, of which most important are considered the ones in the Eastern Mediterranean and the Mauritania coast (Reijnders et al., 1993, 1997). For most of the species' range, data on the status of the (sub)populations and the availability of suitable habitat are limited. In the island of Cyprus, data on the species have been limited to past reports of animal sightings, which have diminished in recent years leading to the hypothesis that the species may have become extinct.

In May 1997, a field survey was conducted along the western and southern coasts of the island of Cyprus (part of the island that is under the Cyprus Government control). More specifically the survey covered the total length of the coastline from Khrysokhou Bay, in the west part of the island, to Cape Greco, in the Southeast part. The survey was carried out by the Cyprus Wildlife Society, in collaboration with Cypriot authorities (Ministry of Agriculture and Natural Resources, Department of Fisheries), and MOm-Hellenic Society for the Study and Protection of the Monk Seal. The whole expedition was financially supported by SPA/RAC of the UNEP/MAP.

The island has a morphologically and geologically variable coastline of 772 km length. About 50% of this coastline is accessible, either being under the control of the Government of the Republic of Cyprus or found in the two British Sovereign Base Areas. Consequently only this part was surveyed.



Objectives of the Study

The objectives of this particular survey were:

  • the identification and localization of any possible monk seal shelters within the study area,
  • the evaluation of the suitability of these habitats,
  • the verification of the existence of monk seal individuals within the study area, and
  • the verification of the use of these habitats by seals.


Materials and Methods

The Department of Fisheries' surveillance boat "AMPHITRITI" was used as a base by the research team and a 4m. inflatable with a light, 4 HP out-board engine was used for the detailed examination of the coastline.

The following persons participated in the field survey:

    Dr. Andreas Demetropoulos, Department of Fisheries
    Mr. Panayiotis Dendrinos, MOm/HSSPMS
    Mr. Andreas Pistentis, Department of Fisheries
    Dr. Myroula Hatjichristophorou, CWS
    Mr. Simon Demetropoulos, CWS

The Mediterranean Monk Seal, at least nowadays, when on land seeks refuge in isolated coastal caves (seal shelters). In such seal shelters one or more entrances (underwater or not) lead to a dry flat surface consisting of sand, pebbles, boulders or rock, where the seals haul-out in order to rest or give birth to their offspring. The field team circumnavigated and examined carefully the total length of the coastline within the study area. The team members examined in detail every possible cave entrance. The team members entered the caves by swimming/snorkelling. The suitable caves (seal shelters) were localised by a GPS receiver, measured and sketched.

The method used by the researchers for approaching and examining the caves has been standardised and tested for a number of years in the area of the National Marine Park of Alonnissos, N. Sporades, Greece, during the long-term monitoring of the monk seal population. According to this method the team approaches the shelters and, depending on the cave, enters each shelter with a dinghy, rowing, or by snorkelling. Using the minimal light source a team member checks the shelter for the presence of any animal:

  • If no animal is found, any signs of previous seal presence are recorded. These signs are: tracks of movement and hollows or depressions from animals laying on the beach surface, smell from the animal, fecal matter deposited on the beach or on the surfaces of the cave, any hair that has fallen from an animal, or any other evidence (saliva, blood, placenta, etc.). The date, time of visit, location, state of the shelter, and findings are noted.
  • If an animal is found within the shelter, then all visible characteristics (size, developmental stage, coloration, external skin marks or scars, overall status of the animal, sex) are recorded. Depending on the specific circumstances of each case and when possible (e.g. animal sleeping), a photograph of the animal is taken for a permanent record of the encounter with the specific individual. It is important to mention that all the above process lasts less than 2 minutes.

The methodology has as central consideration to minimise disturbance to the monk seals in the process of collecting the necessary data. Thus, at any time when animals observed appear to be disturbed by the presence of the researchers within a shelter, the visit is terminated and the team leaves the area.

In parallel, recent information on monk seal sightings were collected through interviews with locals (mainly fishermen).


Results

During the survey approximately 150 nautical miles of coastline were examined in detail for the existence of suitable monk seal habitats. Within the study area 18 different suitable monk seal habitats (sea caves) were identified, explored and charted. Eight of the caves were recorded in the part of coastline north of Paphos up to the Cape Yeronissos (Cave Areas 3,4). Two were recorded in the area of Khrysokhou Bay (Cave Areas 1,2). Six caves were recorded in the area of Cape Gata (Akrotiri, Cave Area 5), one cave was recorded in the area of Cape Pyla (Cave Area 6) and one in the area of Ayia Napa (Cave Areas 7). Four of the above caves/seal shelters were evaluated as being suitable for breeding. Detailed characteristics for the caves identified are provided in the table below.

All the caves were examined thoroughly for the existence of individual seals or for any evidence of recent use by animals. In none of the above shelters were individual seals observed by the team members during the survey. However, an important finding was the existence of seal scats (excrements) in one of the caves (West Coast of Akamas, Cave Area 3). Upon detailed examination, the excrements were found to be fresh (left by the animal, on the rocky beach of the cave, within the last 12 hours). They contained a number of small fishbones. In addition, a seal track was recorded in a cave (Cave Area 2, western part of Khrysokhou Bay).

The above findings provide evidence that monk seal individual(s), although rare, are still found in Cyprus and that, during the study period, used two suitable caves in this part of the Cypriot coastline.
 

Characteristic entrances of sea caves (suitable monk seal shelters) recorded during the study.
 
Sketches of suitable monk seal shelters recorded during the study. (Click on maps to enlarge)
 
 
RECENT RECORDS OF MONK SEALS

LOCATION
DATE/YEAR
COMMENTS
Thalassines Spilies 1988 A single animal
Kioni Island 1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996 Reports mainly of a single animal, but two were once mentioned.
Cape Yeronissos 1988, 1989, 1990, 1997, 1998 A single animal
Ayia Napa-Cape Pyla 1990 A single animal seen twice
Ayia Napa June 1998 One animal seen near caves and also near fishing harbour
Larnaca Bay February 1997 One animal seen near Larnaca fishing harbour and near Cape Kiti
Mazotos February 1997 One animal seen
Fontana Amorosa (N. Akamas) 1997 One animal seen on several consecutive days
Halavron cave area March 1997 One animal seen in 1997. Several sightings in 1998 near cave.
Limassol Summer 1998 One small animal seen regularly near an offshore fish farm
Cape Gata February 1997, 1998 One animal seen in 1997. One large animal seen several times in cave area
Polis Dasoudi August 1998 One animal seen at 1 km from shore — approached fishing boat
 
 
CHARACTERISTICS OF SEAL SHELTERS

Cave code
Location
(GPS plotted)
Multiple Entrances
Entrance Direction (degrees)
Beach Area
(m2)
Suitability of Shelter
Evidence of Seal Use
Seals Observed
CYPP 1
+
-
-
-
Resting
-
-
CYPP 2
+
2
210
20
Breeding
-
-
CYPP 3
+
2
180
25
Breeding
-
-
CYPP 4
+
-
190
12
Resting
-
-
CYPP 5
+
-
180
10
Resting
-
-
CYPP 6
+
2
260
40
Resting
-
-
CYPP 7
+
-
-
7
Resting
-
-
CYPY 8
+
-
230
8
Resting
+
-
CYPK 9
+
-
30
20
Resting
+
-
CYPK10
+
-
30
40
Breeding
-
-
CYPA11
+
2
210
20
Resting
-
-
CYPA12
+
-
200
15
Resting
-
-
CYPA13
+
2
210
25
Breeding
-
-
CYPA14
+
2
130/210
5
Resting
-
-
CYPA15
+
-
210
8
Resting
-
-
CYPA16
+
-
280
6
Resting
-
-
CYPCP17
+
-
210
15
Resting
-
-
CYPAN18
+
-
290
-
Resting
-
-
 
 
Discussion

It is clear that though there has been a serious decline in the monk seal population in Cyprus, the species cannot be considered extinct on the island. We found evidence that at least a small number of animals continues to survive, using mainly the shelters found at Cape Gata and at the west and north-west part of the island. Apart from the direct evidence on the use of caves by the seals collected during this survey, records of recent monk seal sightings further support the use of these areas by the species.

Due to the fact that the survey was undertaken during late spring, a period of the year when seals least frequent caves (Dendrinos et al., 1994), the results obtained must be considered as conservative. Thus, in order to evaluate the status of the species in the island, additional fieldwork should be carried out throughout the year and especially during the reproductive period.

In addition to monitoring and surveys, however important they may be in enhancing our knowledge, effective conservation will be achieved only when critical habitats for the species receive appropriate protection. The status of this species, as one of the most endangered marine mammals in the world, more than justifies the implementation of effective conservation measures.

The two caves, in which direct evidence of the presence of seals was recorded, are already included in the management plans for the core zone of the protected area of Akamas. It can therefore be assumed that these two locations will be protected, from the land side at least, with the implementation of the Akamas management plan. Appropriate protection measures also need to be designed for these caves as regards the adjacent marine area. Similar protection measures have to be envisaged for the other suitable-for- breeding areas recorded, and especially those of Cape Gata and Thalassines Spilies.


References

Dendrinos, P., E. Tounta, S. Kotomatas, & A. Kottas. 1994. Recent data on the Mediterranean Monk Seal population of the Northern Sporades. Bios (Macedonia, Greece) 2: 11-16.

IUCN. 1996. 1996 IUCN red list of threatened animals. The IUCN Species Survival Commission. International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources, Gland, Switzerland: 1-368 + 10 annexes.

Reijnders, P., S. Brasseur, J. van der Torn, P. van der Wolf, I. Boyd, J. Harwood, D. Lavigne, & L. Lowry, eds. 1993. Seals, Fur Seals, Sea Lions and Walrus. Status survey and Conservation Action Plan. IUCN/SSG Seal Specialist Group. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland: vi + 1-88p.

Reijnders, P.J.H., G. Verriopoulos, S.M.J.M. Brasseur, eds. 1997. Status of Pinnipeds Relevant to the European Union. IBN Scientific Contributions 8. Institute for Forestry and Nature Research (IBN-DLO), Wageningen, the Netherlands: 1-195.

 

This poster was presented at the 8th International Congress on the Zoogeography and Ecology of Greece and Adjacent Regions, Kavala, Greece, 17-21 May 1999.



                                    

Copyright © 2000 MOm, Cyprus Wildlife Society, P. Dendrinos, A. Demetropoulos, The Monachus Guardian. All Rights Reserved